No, an illegal immigrant should not be admitted to the bar

American Thinker

We just learned that California is doing something rather unusual. They are allowing an illegal immigrant to join the state bar:


“As a teenager in Northern California, Sergio Garcia worked in the almond fields and in a grocery store, earning his way through college and then law school.

He passed the California bar exam on his first try, something just half of all candidates do.  

But when it came time to apply for his law license, Mr. Garcia encountered a formidable hurdle: Because he had come from Mexico illegally, he could not become a lawyer.   

That changed Thursday when the California Supreme Court ruled unanimously that a law passed last fall by the Legislature allowed Mr. Garcia, 36, to be admitted to the state bar and practice law.

What it did not do is address the fact that under federal law, no law firm, business or public agency can legally hire him.”


Let’s look at this story because it speaks volumes about the cowardice of the liberal elites running California over the cliff.

 First, I am a supporter of a modified plan that allows young people here an opportunity to get on some path to legalization.  We are talking about young people who came here with their parents years ago.  Many of them are in school, colleges or even willing to wear the uniform.  Again, I have no problem with directing them to a window and conditionally getting them on some path to legalization.

 Second, Sergio Garcia’s story is remarkable.  I love his work habits.  At the same time, my parents had a good work ethic too and we came here legally.  In other words, a lot of LEGAL immigrants have also worked very hard, from my uncle picking tomatoes in Florida to my dad working as a bellboy in a Wisconsin hotel.

 Third, the Democrats had control of the US Senate and Congress and never did a darn thing about “The Dream Act.”  It failed in 2010. 

 Fourth, what is the point of legal residency if an illegal resident can get a drivers’ license or become a member of the state bar?  

 Where does this stop?

 Democrats, and the liberal elite, are afraid of telling illegal immigrants two simple facts:

 1) We respect you but our immigration laws matter, too; and,

 2) We have a legal way for you to come into the country.  Go to the consulate in your town and inquire about it.

 By the way, how is Segio Garcia going to take the oath about upholding the laws of the country or state? I can’t wait to hear about that one! 

 Maybe the liberal elite will tell us that we need to “update the oath”!

Read more: Follow us: @AmericanThinker on Twitter | AmericanThinker on Facebook

6 thoughts on “No, an illegal immigrant should not be admitted to the bar

  1. It is unbelievable that an Illegal can get on the bar in California. I am still dumbfounded that the term illegal has a different meaning for those crossing our border illegally but a crime for everything else. If the tide was turned Mexico would not hesitate to throw an American in jail.
    I understand this person came here as a child which may not be his fault but should at least apply for legal status and be Approved before he has any rights here.
    Our nation is struggling already and cases like this only hurts our credibility.

  2. Reblogged this on My opinions on America's issues and commented:
    What next an Illegal running for Governor in California? This state has stronger ties to Mexico than the United States. I strongly believe that Mexico can have California.

  3. Illegal means not allowed by law, period. U.S. law states that it is unlawful to enter this country illegally. I understand helping those in need because breaking the law is not the way.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s